No spam - just the latest insights!
Join over 30,000 industry professionals who subscribe for free
Subscribe for free!
We'll never share your information or send you spam
Bill is a member of the Firm’s Corporate, Securities and Corporate Finance, and Mergers and Acquisitions groups. He advises public and private companies on mergers and acquisitions in the power, renewable energy and infrastructure sectors across Canada and internationally. A leader in ESG and sustainable finance, Bill represents Dentons Canada in global green and transition finance initiatives and advises on green, transition, sustainability and sustainability linked loans and bonds. He also holds the ICD.D designation and has completed the Board Oversight of Climate Change Course.
Kristina Zaytseva is a student-at-law joining the Firm’s Corporate, Securities and Corporate Finance, and Mergers and Acquisitions groups in the Calgary, Canada office as an associate. She is developing a broad practice spanning mergers and acquisitions, corporate reorganizations, securities and capital markets, and commercial transactions, with a strong interest in ESG and sustainable finance. She summered with Dentons after her first year of law school and articled with Dentons after graduating from the University of Alberta’s Faculty of Law.
The regulatory landscape for environmental, social and governance (“ESG”) and sustainable finance matters in Canada has seen significant movement over the past couple of years. The Canadian Securities Administrators (“CSA”) have paused their work on mandatory climate-related disclosure, the federal government has amended key aspects of the 2024 anti-greenwashing provisions of the , and a Made-in-Canada sustainable investment taxonomy is now under development.1Competition Act, RSC 1985, c C-34. Policy and regulatory changes in the United States (“United States” or “US”) across climate disclosure, sustainability standards, diversity, equity and inclusion (“DEI”), proxy advisory services, shareholder engagement and the regulation of financial institutions are also increasingly influencing how Canadian companies and regulators are responding. With the Canadian and United States capital markets deeply interconnected, these developments are likely to carry growing implications for Canadian businesses over time, even where the immediate changes are directed at United States markets. Each of these developments is examined in turn below.
On 18 October 2021, the CSA published proposed National Instrument 51-107 – Disclosure of Climate-related Matters and its proposed Companion Policy 51-107CP (together, the “Climate Disclosure Proposals”) for comment.2CSA Notice and Request for Comment, Proposed National Instrument 51-107 – Disclosure of Climate-related Matters (18 October 2021), online: Alberta Securities Commission. The Climate Disclosure Proposals contemplated mandatory climate-related disclosure requirements for reporting issuers based on the four core elements of the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (“TCFD”) recommendations, namely, governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics and targets, and would have required disclosure of Scope 1, 2 and 3 greenhouse gas (“GHG”) emissions on a “comply-or-explain” basis.3CSA Notice and Request for Comment, Proposed National Instrument 51-107 – Disclosure of Climate-related Matters (18 October 2021) at 7-8, 41, online: Alberta Securities Commission; CSA Notice and Request for Comment, Proposed National Instrument 51-107 – Disclosure of Climate-related Matters (18 October 2021), online: Alberta Securities Commission.
The Climate Disclosure Proposals have not yet been finalized, as the CSA continues to assess international developments. In October 2022, the CSA indicated that it was “actively considering” the impact of proposals from the International Sustainability Standards Board (“ISSB”) and the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) on the Canadian climate-related disclosure rule.4Canadian Securities Administrators, “Canadian Securities Regulators Consider Impact of International Developments on Proposed Climate-Related Disclosure Rule” (12 October 2022), online: Canadian Securities Administrators. In June 2023, the ISSB published its final Climate-Related Disclosure Standard (International Financial Reporting Standards (“IFRS”) S2, or “IFRS S2”) and General Standard for Sustainability-Related Financial Information (“IFRS S1”), which consolidate the TCFD recommendations into a global baseline of sustainability disclosures.5IFRS Foundation, “ISSB Issues Inaugural Global Sustainability Disclosure Standards” (26 June 2023), online: IFRS; IFRS Foundation, “About the International Sustainability Standards Board”, online: IFRS. In July 2023, the CSA announced its intention to conduct further consultations to adopt disclosure standards based on the ISSB Standards, with appropriate modifications for the Canadian context.6Canadian Securities Administrators, “Canadian Securities Administrators Statement on Proposed Climate-Related Disclosure Requirements” (5 July 2023), online: Alberta Securities Commission.
In December 2024, the Canadian Sustainability Standards Board (“CSSB”) issued its inaugural voluntary sustainability standards, which are generally aligned with the ISSB Standards except for a few transitional matters relating to Scope 3 emissions, quantitative scenario analysis and the general timing of disclosure.7Canadian Securities Administrators, “CSA Updates Market on Approach to Climate-Related and Diversity-Related Disclosure Projects” (23 April 2025), online: Alberta Securities Commission; Canadian Sustainability Standards Board, CSDS 1 – General Requirements for Disclosure of Sustainability-related Financial Information and CSDS 2 – Climate-related Disclosures (December 2024), online: Financial Reporting & Assurance Standards Canada. The CSA described the CSSB Standards as providing “a useful voluntary disclosure framework” for sustainability and climate-related disclosure, and indicated that it would continue to work toward a revised mandatory climate-related disclosure rule informed by those standards.8Canadian Securities Administrators, “CSA Updates Market on Approach to Climate-Related and Diversity-Related Disclosure Projects” (23 April 2025), online: Alberta Securities Commission.
However, on 23 April 2025, the CSA announced that it was pausing its work on the development of a new mandatory climate-related disclosure rule, citing the rapidly and significantly changed global economic and geopolitical landscape, increased uncertainty and rising competitiveness concerns for Canadian issuers.9Canadian Securities Administrators, “CSA Updates Market on Approach to Climate-Related and Diversity-Related Disclosure Projects” (23 April 2025), online: Alberta Securities Commission. The decision came shortly after the SEC voted on 27 March 2025 to end its defense of its own climate disclosure rules, adding further uncertainty to the sustainability disclosure landscape across North America.10U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Press Release, “SEC Votes to End Defense of Climate Disclosure Rules” (27 March 2025), online: U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
Notwithstanding the pause, the CSA emphasized that climate-related risks remain “a mainstream business issue” and that securities legislation already requires issuers to disclose material climate-related risks affecting their business in the same way that issuers are required to disclose other types of material information.11Canadian Securities Administrators, “CSA Updates Market on Approach to Climate-Related and Diversity-Related Disclosure Projects” (23 April 2025), online: Alberta Securities Commission. The CSA encouraged issuers to refer to the CSSB Standards when preparing their sustainability and climate-related disclosures, and indicated that it will monitor domestic and international regulatory developments and expects to revisit the project in future years to finalize requirements for issuers, while continuing to address any misleading disclosure, including greenwashing.
While mandatory climate-related disclosure for public companies under securities law remains in development, a mandatory regime is already in force for Canada’s largest federally regulated financial institutions. Canada’s domestic systemically important banks and internationally active insurance groups headquartered in Canada are required to make climate-related financial disclosures under the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (“OSFI”) Guideline B-15 on Climate Risk Management.12Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, “Climate Risk Management” (7 March 2025); Dentons, “Regulatory trends to watch: Climate-related disclosure requirements in Canada” (24 February 2025). Initially published in March 2023 and most recently updated in March 2025, Guideline B-15 requires these institutions to make climate-related disclosures aligned with the CSSB Standards, including in respect of governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics and targets, subject to certain transitional provisions.13Dentons, “Aligning OSFI’s Guideline B-15 on Climate Risk Management with New CSSB Standards” (11 March 2025). OSFI has indicated that Guideline B-15 will continue to evolve as domestic and international climate-related disclosure standards and best practices develop.
On 20 June 2024, Bill C-59, the Fall Economic Statement Implementation Act (“Bill C-59”), received Royal Assent, representing the third wave of amendments to the as part of the federal government’s broader project to modernize the statute.1414. Bill C-59, Fall Economic Statement Implementation Act, 2023, S.C. 2024, c. 15 (Royal Assent 20 June 2024); Dentons, “Bill C-59’s third wave of changes to the Competition Act passed” (28 June 2024). Among its many changes, Bill C-59 introduced new “anti-greenwashing” provisions to the .15Bill C-59, Fall Economic Statement Implementation Act, 2023, S.C. 2024, c. 15 (Royal Assent 20 June 2024); Dentons, “Bill C-59’s third wave of changes to the Competition Act passed” (28 June 2024).
Of particular significance was a new provision requiring that representations about the environmental benefits of a business or business activity (like “net-zero” targets) be based on “adequate and proper substantiation in accordance with internationally recognized methodology.”16Competition Act, RSC 1985, c C-34, s 74.01(1)(b.2) [Past version: in force between 2025-06-20 and 2026-03-25]. This introduced a reverse onus, requiring businesses to prove their representations were properly substantiated.17Competition Act, RSC 1985, c C-34, ss 74.01(1)(b.1), 74.01(1)(b.2); Dentons, “Bill C-59’s third wave of changes to the Competition Act passed” (28 June 2024). The amendments also expanded private rights of action. Effective June 2025, private parties could seek leave from the Competition Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) to bring claims in respect of business activity representations, with the Tribunal empowered to grant leave where it was satisfied that doing so was in the “public interest.”18Competition Act, RSC 1985, c C-34, s 103.1; Dentons, “Bill C-59’s third wave of changes to the Competition Act passed” (28 June 2024).
The breadth and ambiguity of these provisions prompted significant concern across the Canadian business community. A representation about a business or business activity could be neither false nor materially misleading and still contravene the if it was not substantiated in accordance with an “internationally recognized methodology,” a term that was not defined in the statute and for which no authoritative guidance existed.19Sonya Savage & Heather Exner-Pirot, “A Failure of Process and Policy” at 16 (26 February 2025), online: Canadian Chamber of Commerce. These concerns were compounded by the absence of any transition period, meaning all existing disclosure was immediately subject to the new substantiation requirements.20Competition Bureau Canada, “Environmental claims and the Competition Act” (5 June 2025, updated 27 March 2026), Q&A #4–5. Penalties for non-compliance could reach up to C$10 million for a first offence (C$15 million for repeat conduct), or three times the value of the benefit derived from the conduct, or 3% of a corporation’s annual worldwide gross revenues where the benefit cannot be reasonably determined, whichever is greater.21Competition Act, RSC 1985, c C-34, s 74.1(1).
Many businesses, particularly in the energy sector, responded by withdrawing or limiting their environmental disclosures, a phenomenon described as “greenhushing.”22Sonya Savage & Heather Exner-Pirot, “A Failure of Process and Policy” at 9, 26, 28 (26 February 2025), online: Canadian Chamber of Commerce. In the 2025 Federal Budget, released on 4 November 2025, the federal government acknowledged that the greenwashing provisions were “creating investment uncertainty and having the opposite of the desired effect,” with some parties slowing or reversing efforts to protect the environment.23Government of Canada, “Canada Strong: Budget 2025” (4 November 2025), Chapter 1, p 113.
The government accordingly moved to walk back two key aspects of the business activity provisions as part of a broader Climate Competitiveness Strategy outlined in the 2025 Federal Budget, while maintaining protections against false claims.24Government of Canada, “Canada Strong: Budget 2025” (4 November 2025), Chapter 1, p 16; Dentons, “Recent legislative developments relating to greenwashing and environmental claims in Canada” (16 December 2025). Bill C-15, the Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1 (“Bill C-15”), was introduced on 18 November 2025 and received Royal Assent on 26 March 2026, bringing the amendments into force.25Bill C-15, Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1, 1st Sess., 45th Parl., 2025 (Royal Assent 26 March 2026).
Bill C-15 amended the business activity provision in two respects.26Bill C-15, Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1, 1st Sess., 45th Parl., 2025 (Royal Assent 26 March 2026), s 597. First, it removed the requirement that environmental claims about a business or business activity be substantiated “in accordance with internationally recognized methodology.”27Bill C-15, Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1, 1st Sess., 45th Parl., 2025 (Royal Assent 26 March 2026), s 597(1). Such claims must still be based on “adequate and proper substantiation,” but the additional hurdle of demonstrating compliance with an internationally recognized methodology has been eliminated.28Bill C-15, Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1, 1st Sess., 45th Parl., 2025 (Royal Assent 26 March 2026), s 597(1); Dentons, “Recent legislative developments relating to greenwashing and environmental claims in Canada” (16 December 2025). Second, Bill C-15 removed the ability for private parties to obtain leave from the Tribunal to prosecute non-compliant environmental claims about a business or business activity, with enforcement of the business activity provision now lying exclusively with the Competition Bureau (the “Bureau”).29Bill C-15, Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 1, s 597(2); Dentons, “Recent legislative developments relating to greenwashing and environmental claims in Canada” (16 December 2025). This change responded to concerns that third-party actions created litigation uncertainty and discouraged companies from sharing legitimate climate-related information.30Government of Canada, “Canada Strong: Budget 2025” (4 November 2025), Chapter 1, p 113; Dentons, “Recent legislative developments relating to greenwashing and environmental claims in Canada” (16 December 2025).
The rules for product-related environmental claims were not affected by Bill C-15, and private parties retain the ability to challenge environmental claims that are false or misleading under the general deceptive marketing provisions of the31Dentons, “Recent legislative developments relating to greenwashing and environmental claims in Canada” (16 December 2025). . For business activity claims, however, the Bureau is now the sole enforcer, and the guidance it has issued on the “adequate and proper substantiation” standard will be the primary reference point for compliance going forward.32Dentons, “Recent legislative developments relating to greenwashing and environmental claims in Canada” (16 December 2025).
In September 2022, Canada’s Sustainable Finance Action Council (“SFAC”) published its Taxonomy Roadmap Report, proposing a voluntary taxonomy to benchmark and standardize economic activities aligned with Canada’s commitment to achieving net-zero emissions by 2050.33Sustainable Finance Action Council, Taxonomy Roadmap Report: Mobilizing Finance for Sustainable Growth by Defining Green and Transition Investments (September 2022). The report was endorsed by Canada’s 25 largest financial institutions.34Business Future Pathways, Developing Canada’s Sustainable Investment Guidelines (18 December 2025). The federal government subsequently committed to developing a sustainable finance taxonomy in the 2023 Fall Economic Statement and 2024 Federal Budget, and on 9 October 2024 announced a plan to deliver voluntary Made-in- Canada sustainable investment guidelines (also referred to as the “taxonomy”) as a tool for investors, lenders and other stakeholders to identify “green” and “transition” economic activities.35Department of Finance Canada, 2023 Fall Economic Statement, Chapter 3, “Sustainable Finance Action.” (21 November 2023); Dentons, “Government of Canada announces intention to introduce mandatory climate disclosures for federal corporations and plans to create Made-in-Canada sustainable investment guidelines” (11 October 2024); Department of Finance Canada, “Government advances Made-in-Canada sustainable investment guidelines to accelerate progress to net-zero emissions by 2050” (9 October 2024).
The taxonomy would define two categories of economic activities, distinguishing between “green” activities, being low or zero-emitting activities that do not have material Scope 1 and 2 emissions, with low or zero downstream Scope 3 emissions, and that sell into or benefit from markets expected to grow in the global net-zero transition, and “transition” activities, being decarbonizing activities that have material Scope 1 and 2 emissions but that do not face immediate demand-side risk and do not create carbon lock-in or path dependency.36Department of Finance Canada, “Government advances Made-in-Canada sustainable investment guidelines to accelerate progress to net-zero emissions by 2050” (9 October 2024).
The taxonomy would focus on priority sectors including electricity, transportation, buildings, agriculture and forestry, manufacturing, and extractives, including mineral extraction and processing, and natural gas.37Department of Finance Canada, “Government advances Made-in-Canada sustainable investment guidelines to accelerate progress to net-zero emissions by 2050” (9 October 2024). With respect to natural gas, new production is not anticipated to be eligible, although eligibility criteria for activities that significantly decarbonize existing production could be developed, provided they are consistent with the taxonomy’s guiding principles.38Department of Finance Canada, “Government advances Made-in-Canada sustainable investment guidelines to accelerate progress to net-zero emissions by 2050” (9 October 2024). More broadly, Canada’s approach to defining transition pathways for emissions-intensive sectors is unique among global taxonomies, positioning it to demonstrate leadership for other resource-based economies.39Sustainable Finance Action Council, “Green and Transition Taxonomy Roadmap Questions and Answers – Brief to House of Commons Standing Committee on Finance” (23 June 2023).
To operationalize the taxonomy, the federal government announced two years of seed funding in December 2025 and appointed the Canadian Climate Institute, in collaboration with Business Future Pathways, to establish the governance structure for its development.40Climate Institute, “Developing Canada’s Sustainable Investment Guidelines” (18 December 2025); Department of Finance Canada, “Government announces next steps toward made-in-Canada sustainable investment guidelines” (18 December 2025). An independent Appointment Committee selected the members of a new Taxonomy and Transition Planning Council (the “Council”), which was announced on 8 April 2026.41Business Future Pathways, Inaugural Leadership of Canadian Sustainable Finance Taxonomy Announced (8 April 2026). The Council is expected to finalize investment guidelines for three priority sectors by the end of 2026 and complete three additional priority sectors by fall 2027, with a methods and framework report expected in summer 2026.42Business Future Pathways, Developing Canada’s Sustainable Investment Guidelines (18 December 2025); Canadian Climate Institute, Canada’s new taxonomy council has a big job ahead. Here’s why it matters. (14 April 2026).
The Council’s mandate is to ensure that the taxonomy is science-based, aligned with the objectives of the Paris Agreement, interoperable with leading international taxonomies while reflecting Canada’s economic context, and that it integrates do-no-significant-harm considerations, including environmental, social and Indigenous perspectives.43Business Future Pathways, Call for Applications (January 2026).
With close to 70 sustainable finance taxonomies currently in use or in development around the world, including by almost all of Canada’s major trading partners, the taxonomy is expected to be an important tool for aligning Canada’s sustainable finance infrastructure with international standards.44Business Future Pathways Canada, Taxonomy (January 2026). Once finalized, the taxonomy is expected to complement the federal government’s broader suite of $93 billion in tax credits for eligible clean investments introduced since 2023, and to assist businesses in navigating compliance with the ’s provisions on greenwashing.45Government of Canada, “Government of Canada Launches the First Clean Economy Investment Tax Credits” (21 June 2024). The federal government has also committed to issuing Canada’s first-ever transition bonds by 2027, with at least $10 billion per year to finance projects that help industrial and agricultural sectors reduce emissions and improve competitiveness.46Liberal Party of Canada, Build (2025).
The ESG regulatory and policy landscape in the United States has shifted significantly since early 2025 through executive action, regulatory retrenchment and diverging institutional investor priorities. These developments have had a direct and observable effect on Canadian companies, particularly those with significant United States operations, and on Canadian regulators calibrating their own responses. The cross-border influence has been most pronounced in DEI, but is also evident in the proxy advisory sector, shareholder engagement practices and climate-related disclosure.
The most significant area of cross-border influence has been in DEI. In early 2025, President Trump signed a suite of executive orders overturning DEI programs across the US federal government and directing federal agencies to investigate diversity programs at publicly traded corporations, non-profits, colleges and foundations.47Dentons, “The red glare: Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Climate disclosure and DEI” (18 February 2025). In response, numerous US companies have scaled back externally apparent DEI programs and reduced or eliminated public disclosure on DEI matters.48Dentons, “The red glare: Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Climate disclosure and DEI” (18 February 2025).
US federal regulatory bodies have also begun to act. The United States Federal Communications Commission announced an investigation into a large US media company for “possibly promoting invidious forms of DEI,” raising the question of whether other federal agencies that Canadian companies routinely engage with, like the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission and the Federal Trade Commission, will take similar steps.49Dentons, “The red glare: Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Climate disclosure and DEI” (18 February 2025); Justin Bachman, “Comcast-NBCUniversal faces FCC probe over ‘invidious’ DEI policies” (13 February 2025). On 26 March 2026, the administration extended these measures further, signing an Executive Order requiring all federal contracts to include a clause prohibiting “racially discriminatory DEI activities,” with agencies authorized to cancel, terminate or suspend contracts for non-compliance.50The White House, “Fact Sheet: President Donald J. Trump Addresses DEI Discrimination by Federal Contractors” (26 March 2026).
These developments have direct implications for Canadian businesses. Canadian public companies face a layered set of diversity disclosure obligations under Toronto Stock Exchange (“TSX”) rules, securities law, the Canada Business Corporations Act, and from governance rating organizations and proxy advisory firms.51Dentons, “The red glare: Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Climate disclosure and DEI” (18 February 2025). Notwithstanding these obligations, a survey of proxy circulars filed by 17 large Canadian public companies with significant United States operations found that in 2025, these companies made fewer references to diversity matters beyond mandatory disclosures compared to 2024, with many providing only the required disclosures and placing less emphasis on voluntary, expansive statements.52Dentons, “The ESG Reset: Legal and Regulatory Developments Shaping Canadian Business.” More broadly, for the first time in over a decade, disclosure rates on key diversity data points have declined across Canadian public companies.53Sarah Dobson, “With disclosure on the decline in Canada, is the commitment to DEI still there?” (5 November 2025). Increasingly, companies are articulating business and strategic reasons to support their approach to DEI.54Sarah Dobson, “With disclosure on the decline in Canada, is the commitment to DEI still there?” (5 November 2025).
Canadian regulators have responded in divergent ways. On 23 April 2025, the CSA paused its proposal for new diversity and board renewal disclosure requirements, explicitly to “support Canadian markets and issuers as they adapt to the recent developments in the U.S. and globally,” indicating that it expects to revisit the project in future years.55CSA, “CSA updates market on approach to climate-related and diversity-related disclosure projects” (23 April 2025). The federal government, however, moved in the opposite direction, proposing on 15 February 2025 new Diversity Information Disclosure Regulations for federally regulated financial institutions.56The Diversity Information Disclosure (Trust and Loan Companies) Regulations, the Diversity Information Disclosure (Banks and Bank holding Companies) Regulations, and the Diversity Information Disclosure (Insurance Companies and Insurance Holding Companies) Regulations, published in the Canada Gazette Part I, Vol. 159, No. 7 (15 February 2025) (collectively, the “Proposed Diversity Regulations”); Dentons, “Proposed Diversity Disclosure Requirements for distributing federal financial institutions” (26 February 2025). For Canadian issuers that are dual-listed or that have significant United States operational footprints, compliance with Canadian mandatory diversity disclosure requirements necessarily involves reporting on diversity policies and programs at a time when United States regulatory bodies are actively discouraging such initiatives.
In response to these regulatory pressures and shifting stewardship priorities among their clients, the proxy advisory sector has undergone what has been described as a structural transformation in how proxy advice is developed and delivered.57Dentons, “Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Proxy voting changes” (12 November 2025); Kingsdale Advisors, “AI, Proxy Voting and Shareholder Activism” (2025). On 11 February 2025, Institutional Shareholder Services Inc. (“ISS”) announced that it would no longer consider the gender, racial or ethnic diversity of board members when making voting recommendations at US companies, citing the executive orders on DEI.58ISS Stoxx, “Statement Regarding Consideration of Diversity Factors in U.S. Director Election Assessments” (11 February 2025). Several large US asset managers have since reduced their reliance on ISS and Glass, Lewis & Co. (“Glass Lewis”), building internal proxy analysis capabilities supported by proprietary artificial intelligence tools.59Kingsdale Advisors, “AI, Proxy Voting and Shareholder Activism” (2025); Dentons, “The ESG Reset: Legal and Regulatory Developments Shaping Canadian Business.” State Street, Vanguard and BlackRock are now all voting without regard to diversity criteria.60Kingsdale Advisors, “AI, Proxy Voting and Shareholder Activism” (2025); Dentons, “The ESG Reset: Legal and Regulatory Developments Shaping Canadian Business.”
In October 2025, both Glass Lewis and ISS announced a broader shift away from standardized benchmark proxy voting recommendations toward customized, client-specific models.61Dentons, “Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Proxy voting changes” (12 November 2025). Glass Lewis will discontinue its benchmark guidelines beginning with the 2027 proxy season, and ISS has moved from a presumption of supporting environmental and social shareholder proposals to a “case-by-case” evaluation.62Dentons, “Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Proxy voting changes” (12 November 2025). On 11 December 2025, President Trump signed an Executive Order on proxy advisors, expressly naming ISS and Glass Lewis, and directing the SEC to review all rules related to proxy advisors and to revise or rescind provisions inconsistent with the order.63The White House, “Protecting American Investors from Foreign-owned and Politically-Motivated Proxy Advisors” (11 December 2025); Gibson Dunn, “President Trump Issues Executive Order Addressing Proxy Advisors and Shareholder Proposals” (15 December 2025). Notwithstanding these changes, ISS and Glass Lewis maintain their domestic Canadian diversity voting policies unchanged, with both continuing to apply 30% gender diversity thresholds for Canadian-listed companies, but the end of standardized benchmark recommendations is expected to fragment voting behavior and make outcomes less predictable, with longer-term implications for Canadian boards.64Dentons, “Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Proxy voting changes” (12 November 2025); Corporate Governance 2026 Canada TD DS.
The SEC has also signaled a shift in how it views shareholder engagement more broadly. Typical engagement activities, including investor meetings with boards and management on governance, environmental and social matters, may now be characterized as “influencing control,” triggering more onerous disclosure obligations.65Dentons, “The ESG Reset: Legal and Regulatory Developments Shaping Canadian Business.”; Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, “Striking the Balance: Managing Shareholder Engagement in 2025” (25 November 2025). The Chairman of the SEC has outlined a plan to refocus shareholder meetings away from ESG-related proposals, and the SEC has effectively allowed companies to exclude shareholder proposals from proxy materials without staff review for the current proxy season.66Dentons, “The ESG Reset: Legal and Regulatory Developments Shaping Canadian Business.”; Kingsdale Advisors, “2026 Proxy Season Early Insights”; ESG Today, “SEC Chair to Target Proxy Advisors, Investors Over ‘Weaponization of Shareholder Proposals’” (17 November 2025). Many large institutional investors have paused engagement entirely or adopted “sit and listen” approaches.67Dentons, “The ESG Reset: Legal and Regulatory Developments Shaping Canadian Business.”; Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, “Striking the Balance: Managing Shareholder Engagement in 2025” (25 November 2025).
For Canadian companies with United States-based institutional shareholders, these developments are driving more nuanced and less predictable engagement dynamics, requiring boards to be proactive and targeted in their shareholder outreach.68Kingsdale Advisors, “2026 Proxy Season Early Insights”. With the same proxy advisory firms and institutional investors active in both jurisdictions, and the Canadian and US capital markets deeply interconnected, this structural transformation in proxy advice and shareholder engagement is likely to carry longer-term implications for Canadian companies and boards, as voting behavior becomes less standardized and engagement expectations less predictable.
The United States has moved sharply away from mandatory climate-related disclosure at the federal level, a shift that, as discussed above, directly contributed to the CSA’s decision to pause its own mandatory climate-related disclosure project. On 27 March 2025, the SEC voted to end its defense of its March 2024 climate-related disclosure rule, which would have required public companies to report on material climate-related risks and GHG emissions, and on 29 May 2026 it proposed to rescind the rule in its entirety.69U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, “SEC Votes to End Defense of Climate Disclosure Rules” (27 March 2025); U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, “SEC Proposes Rescission of Climate-Related Disclosure Rules” (29 May 2026). The federal government has also targeted climate-related regulation at the state level, with an Executive Order signed on 8 April 2025 directing the Attorney General to identify and challenge state and local laws addressing “climate change” or involving ESG initiatives.70Federal Register, “Protecting American Energy From State Overreach” (8 April 2025). Notwithstanding these federal efforts, several US states, including California, New York and Colorado, have advanced their own climate disclosure laws, creating a patchwork of requirements that Canadian companies with United States operations must navigate.71Dentons, “The ESG Reset: Legal and Regulatory Developments Shaping Canadian Business.”; Asuene, “New York Weakened Its Climate Law — But Corporate Disclosure Obligations Are Getting Stronger” (1 June 2026).
The SEC’s shifting stance on sustainability also puts at risk a longstanding advantage for Canadian issuers accessing United States capital markets. Since 2007, the SEC has permitted foreign private issuers, including Canadian public companies, to file financial statements prepared under IFRS without reconciliation to United States Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (“US GAAP”).72Soyoung Ho, “Chair Paul Atkins: SEC May Reconsider Foreign Companies’ Use of Global Accounting Standards in US” (11 September 2025); Dentons, “The red glare: Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Sustainability disclosure and the SEC” (4 November 2025). The Chairman of the SEC, who was himself an SEC Commissioner when the reconciliation requirement was eliminated, has indicated that the SEC may need to reconsider this position if the IFRS Foundation allows its funding of the ISSB to divert resources from the International Accounting Standards Board, characterizing sustainability-related matters as “specious and speculative issues” and warning that the premise underlying the 2007 decision “may no longer be valid.”73Dentons, “The red glare: Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Sustainability disclosure and the SEC” (4 November 2025); Mark Segal, “SEC Chair Warns IFRS Foundation Over Support for International Sustainability Standards Board” (11 September 2025). Any such revocation would require Canadian public companies that file in the United States as foreign private issuers to prepare or reconcile their financial statements to US GAAP, imposing significant additional cost and complexity on companies that rely on cross-border access to United States capital markets.74Dentons, “The ESG Reset: Legal and Regulatory Developments Shaping Canadian Business.”
The divergence between the two jurisdictions extends to the regulation of financial institutions. In the United States, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (“OCC”) withdrew its participation in the interagency Principles for Climate-Related Financial Risk Management for Large Financial Institutions on 31 March 2025, characterizing them as “overly burdensome and duplicative,” and the OCC, the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation formally rescinded the principles on 16 October 2025.75Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, “OCC Withdraws Principles for Climate-Related Financial Risk Management for Large Financial Institutions” (31 March 2025); Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, “Risk Management: Rescission of Principles for Climate-Related Financial Risk Management for Large Financial Institutions” (16 October 2025). In Canada, OSFI has continued to move in the opposite direction, expanding the scope of Guideline B-15 and its climate risk management and disclosure requirements for federally regulated financial institutions.76Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, “Climate Risk Management” (7 March 2025); Dentons, “The ESG Reset: Legal and Regulatory Developments Shaping Canadian Business.”; Dentons, “The red glare: Watching the impact in Canada of ESG changes in the United States – Sustainability disclosure and the SEC” (4 November 2025). The elimination of climate-related risk management requirements for United States financial institutions, at a time when their Canadian counterparts face expanding obligations, raises questions about the competitive position of Canadian institutions and how far OSFI will advance its climate risk management agenda in the face of these developments.